RE: [xml-dev] Namespaces, Xml Schema Whitespace normalization, xs:anyURI, and URILiterals in XPath 2.0

• To: <lists@...>,"'Michele Vivoda'" <idmichele@...>,<xml-dev@...>
• Subject: RE: [xml-dev] Namespaces, Xml Schema Whitespace normalization, xs:anyURI, and URILiterals in XPath 2.0
• From: "Michael Kay" <mike@...>
• Date: Wed, 29 Mar 2006 23:13:19 +0100
• In-reply-to: <442AE14D.3030706@...>
• Thread-index: AcZTaESktt99VpM1TY+8uwrefsBk7wAE14Og

> Technically this is not a valid URI and therefore not a legal 
> namespace name.

That depends which spec you read. According to the namespaces Rec, any
string is a legal namespace name. Yes, they talk throughout of URIs (or in
1.1, IRIs) but the spec doesn't say it's an error if it's not a URI/IRI, and
I believe the omission is deliberate. Therefore, non-URIs are legal
namespace names.

The Namespaces Rec says: "[Definition:] The attribute's value, a URI
reference, is the namespace name identifying the namespace." But in its
conformance section it doesn't say a document is non-conformant if the value
isn't a valid URI reference; nor does the spec contain any definition or
reference saying exactly what it means by a "URI reference".

The Infoset says: "This specification does not define an information set for
documents which use relative URI references in namespace declarations." This
reflects a lively controversy over whether or not relative namespace URIs
should be resolved against a base URI (the outcome being that no-one could
agree, so they decided to deprecate their use), but it doesn't resolve the
issue of whether a document that says xmlns="####" is
legal/conformant/well-formed or not: let alone xmlns="    ".

Basically, the naming and addressing foundations of XML are a disgraceful
shambles, and anyone building higher-level specs like XSLT and XQuery on
these shaky foundations simply has to improvise.

Michael Kay
http://www.saxonica.com/ 

• Prev by Date: Re: [xml-dev] Namespaces, Xml Schema Whitespace normalization, xs:anyURI, and URILiterals in XPath 2.0
• Next by Date: Re: [xml-dev] Namespaces, Xml Schema Whitespace normalization, xs:anyURI,and URILiterals in XPath 2.0
• Previous by thread: Re: [xml-dev] Namespaces, Xml Schema Whitespace normalization, xs:anyURI, and URILiterals in XPath 2.0
• Next by thread: Re: [xml-dev] Namespaces, Xml Schema Whitespace normalization, xs:anyURI,and URILiterals in XPath 2.0
• Index(es):
  • Date
  • Thread